To take full advantage of this site, please enable your browser's JavaScript feature.
Learn how
CA
ND
Y S
TO
RE
CANDY
CHOCOLATES
FUDGE
GENERAL STORE
Books
Cell Phone Accessories
Clothing
Everything Edible
General Store Staples
Gifts
Handmade Products
Kitchen
Masks, Shields & Sanitizers
Natural Remedies
New England Souvenirs
Puzzles
Soaps
Tea
Toys & Accessories
SALE ITEMS
Byers Choice Sale
Byers Choice Secondary Market Sale
COLLECTIBLES
Byers' Choice Carolers
Ginger Cottages
Secondary Market
Curbside pickup is still available. Self serve displays are out of order.
Toggle navigation
0
CA
ND
Y S
TO
RE
CANDY
CHOCOLATES
FUDGE
GENERAL STORE
Books
Cell Phone Accessories
Clothing
Everything Edible
General Store Staples
Gifts
Handmade Products
Kitchen
Masks, Shields & Sanitizers
Natural Remedies
New England Souvenirs
Puzzles
Soaps
Tea
Toys & Accessories
SALE ITEMS
Byers Choice Sale
Byers Choice Secondary Market Sale
COLLECTIBLES
Byers' Choice Carolers
Ginger Cottages
Secondary Market
OPEN for regular business hours
Home
>
CA
ND
Y S
TO
RE
>
CANDY
>
Candy By Type
>
Nostalgic Candy
Sort By:
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Most Popular
Title
Manufacturer
Newest
Oldest
Availability
30 per page
60 per page
120 per page
180 per page
300 per page
Page
of 5
Jumbo Party Bag
Our Price:
$4.50
Wayside Olde Tyme Tote
Our Price:
$9.99
Employee Favorite Bag - Jackie's Jam-packed Jackpot
Our Price:
$3.85
10 - $1.00 Gift Certificate Wooden Coins
Our Price:
$10.00
SEASONAL - Molasses Puff (6 - 5 oz Bags)
Our Price:
$29.70
Currently Unavailable
SEASONAL - Molasses Puff (24 - 5 oz Bags)
Our Price:
$112.20
Currently Unavailable
Candy Corn - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$6.00
Caramellow's
Our Price:
$2.95
Salt Water Taffy 1 Lb. (16 oz. Box)
Our Price:
$9.95
Assorted Jordan Almonds - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$12.50
Blue Raspberry Rock Candy - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$16.50
Boston Baked Beans - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$8.00
Bullseyes - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$7.00
Candy Blox - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$9.00
Candy Buttons - 8 Count Sheets
Our Price:
$2.00
Cinnamon Imperials - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$8.00
Cherry Nibs - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$6.00
Fireballs - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$8.00
Flying Saucers - Box of 50
Our Price:
$5.00
Fruit Slices - Assorted - 1 LB Tray
Our Price:
$11.00
Good & Plenty - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$6.50
Licorice Pipes
Our Price:
$1.00
Licorice Shoestring - 4 oz Bag
Our Price:
$2.99
Licorice Twizzlers - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$7.00
Marshmallow Peanuts - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$10.00
Non Pareils Dark - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$17.50
Spearmint Leaves - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$5.50
Strawberry Rock Candy - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$16.50
Strawberry Shoestring - 4 oz Bag
Our Price:
$2.99
Strawberry Twizzlers - 1 LB Bag
Our Price:
$7.00